Am I the only one who thought of anti-apartheid activist Dulcie September when news broke that Ambassador Nathi Mthethwa had died in Paris? South Africans have long known that public figures do not simply fall to their deaths from the 22nd floor of a hotel without deeper truths lurking beneath official explanations.

The circumstances surrounding Mthethwa’s death are troubling. The Hyatt Regency Paris Étoile, where he allegedly fell, is only 3.5 kilometres from the South African Embassy, where he had an official residence. Why was the Ambassador at the hotel at all? Who was he meeting that he could not meet at the embassy or his residence? These are questions his diary, his personal assistant, and his secretary should be able to answer.

International law places responsibility on France to ensure the safety of ambassadors on its soil. The French authorities must therefore account for what measures were in place and how such a tragedy could occur under their watch.

There are further pressing concerns. Ambassadors do not drive themselves; if Mthethwa left the embassy, he would have had an official driver. That individual should provide a full account of the journey, while vehicle tracking records — standard for diplomatic cars — must be released.

Reports also claim that Mthethwa’s last phone activity was near Bois de Boulogne, a park not far from the embassy or hotel. If true, this suggests he stopped there before his death. Why was he there, and who was he with?

His final text message, reportedly sent to his wife, must also be verified. Linguistic patterns, spelling, and even emoji use could reveal whether the message was genuinely authored by him. Equally, hotel records and surveillance footage could shed light on whether someone else booked or accessed his room.

Attention should also fall on the embassy itself. Brigadier-General M. Lepheane, the Defence Attaché stationed in Paris since 2021, may hold crucial information about the Ambassador’s final movements.

These are not conspiracies. They are legitimate, uncomfortable truths that must be pursued. Too often in our history, official accounts have smothered the facts. For the sake of transparency, justice, and the dignity of Ambassador Mthethwa’s memory, South Africans must demand a full and independent investigation